i’ve been slowly finishing Careless People. i read the first 80-90% of it very quickly, but it’s been kind of a chore to finish.
i find the author, Sara Wynn-Williams, extremely unlikable and at times more than a little self-serving. it strains belief that she could still believe that facebook was a place to work as a force for moral good when she was ultimately hired in 2011. i understand that not everybody feels the same way about facebook, but i think it was pretty clear even then that it was not a “good” company.
i find too many of her anecdotes to be of the “this was bad and i was there and let me tell you how bad it was!” variety without much in the way of self-awareness or reflection.
in the table of contents, there is a chapter title “Myanmar,” which i imagined was going to deal with facebook’s enabling and promotion of the genocide that took place there. (see: https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2022/09/myanmar-facebooks-systems-promoted-violence-against-rohingya-meta-owes-reparations-new-report/) and it was, sort of, except a lot of it seemed to be focused on the workplace drama and annoyances around facebook’s lack of conscience and accountability, rather than focusing on the atrocities that occurred as a consequence.
after Sara Wynn-Williams buries the lede for a bit, she finally says:
“The unthinkable happens.”
despite the fact that she spent plenty of ink in the previous pages describing how very thinkable it was, but Facebook just didn’t believe it!
she continues:
“In late August, the military launches a campaign of atrocities against the Muslim population that the UN later describes as genocide and crimes against humanity.”
i mean…call it what it is. the whole section is weasel worded, as she dances around it by saying “the unthinkable” or “UN […] describes” without ever actually saying what she believes.
i have more critiques, but in general i think that this book reads more like a prosaic workplace memoir that just so happens to be about facebook than it does a speaking-truth-to-power bombshell whistleblower account.